Intro.
#Three Types of Competitors — Direct, Indirect, and Substitute
| Category | Definition | Healthcare app example |
|---|
| Direct competitor | Same solution, targeting the same customer | Comparable diet apps A, B, and C |
| Indirect competitor | Solves the same problem in a different way | Personal trainers, nutritionist consultations |
| Substitute | The customer chooses not to solve the problem at all | Just living with it, or taking a friend's advice and moving on |
주의
Substitutes are the piece most business plans leave out entirely. If you don't address the possibility that customers simply do nothing, your market-entry strategy will look unrealistic.
02
#The Basic Structure of a Positioning Map
A Positioning Map is a 2x2 matrix built from two axes — X and Y — on which you plot competitors. Good axes have to be variables that customers actually use when making a decision.
- X-axis — price range (low to high) or ease of use
- Y-axis — depth (simple to specialized) or degree of automation
- Place your own company in an empty quadrant (white space)
- Optionally use circle size to represent market share or revenue
03
#Examples of Bad Axis Choices
| Bad axis | Why it's a problem |
|---|
| Good service ~ bad service | A subjective judgment, not a decision variable |
| Uses AI ~ doesn't use AI | Customers don't choose based on whether AI is involved |
| Fast ~ slow | Vague definition, not measurable |
| Innovative ~ traditional | A value judgment, unrelated to how customers decide |
TIP
Before choosing your axes, ask 5-10 prospective customers directly: 'What do you compare when picking a product in this category?' Their answers reveal the real decision variables.
04
#Four Conditions for a Good Axis
- Measurable — expressed in objective units like price (currency), time (minutes), or frequency
- A decision variable — something customers actually use when comparing options
- Reflects your differentiation — your company should land in an empty quadrant
- Simple — expressible in one word, with no elaboration needed
When the axes are well chosen, your differentiation gets visualized automatically. It's often more efficient to work backward: decide which quadrant you want your company to occupy, then find the axes that leave that quadrant empty.
05
#Standard Format for a Competitor Analysis Table
Attaching a competitor analysis table alongside your Positioning Map significantly boosts credibility. The standard format uses these five columns.
| Column | Example |
|---|
| Competitor name | Company A, B, C |
| Core business model | Monthly subscription / usage-based billing / transaction fee |
| Target customer | B2B SMEs / B2C ages 30-40 / global enterprises |
| Key strength | Price, UX, domain expertise, proprietary data, etc. |
| How we differ | One-line differentiator (half the price, localized-first, more automation, etc.) |
주의
In the 'how we differ' column, phrasing like 'we're just better' instantly undermines credibility. Stick to objective, comparable facts.
06
#Describe Your Barrier to Entry and Moat Alongside It
A Positioning Map alone doesn't answer the question 'why can't a bigger company just copy this?' You need to explain whether your differentiation functions as a real barrier to entry, and whether it holds up over time.
- Technology moat — patents, proprietary data, an algorithmic edge
- Network effects — more users drive more value
- Distribution moat — exclusive channels, government certifications, industry licenses
- Brand moat — category recognition, an NPS advantage
- Cost moat — a unit-cost gap from economies of scale
Summary.
#Self-Check Checklist
- Have you identified all three competitor types — direct, indirect, and substitute?
- Are both Positioning Map axes measurable decision variables?
- Is your company placed in an empty quadrant (white space)?
- Are all five columns of the competitor analysis table (name, business model, target, strength, difference) filled in?
- Have you explained whether your differentiation is a barrier to entry that holds up over time?
- Have subjective phrases ('we're better') been replaced with objective comparisons?
CTA
OpenSeed's market and strategy agent automatically checks whether your Positioning Map axes are well chosen, whether your quadrant placement makes sense, and how complete your barrier-to-entry narrative is. Free during the current beta.
Validate Your Positioning Map in 5 Minutes
Our market and strategy agent automatically analyzes your axis choices and the soundness of your differentiation.
🔒 Free during beta · your submission isn't saved
Start Free AI Feedback →