View contents
Article
Technology & Research

Why OpenSeed Uses 17 Evaluation Roles

2026.05.05·6 min·OPENSEED
MENTORING KNOWLEDGE FORChief Analyst

Which produces more useful results when AI reviews a business plan: one generalist perspective, or several roles with distinct areas of focus? OpenSeed defines 17 evaluation roles: seven core and ten professional. Professional roles are matched to the business's relevance, while the separate Chief Report Composer integrates the findings that apply.

Intro.

#The Limits of a Single Generalist Mentor

When one person evaluates an entire business plan — market, technology, finance, team, legal, design, marketing, and more — that one person's strengths, weaknesses, and biases shape the whole result. A mentor who's strong in market analysis tends to go easy on the financials, and vice versa.

  • Blind spots — a mentor's weak areas become weak spots in the review itself
  • Bias — the mentor's industry background and personal preferences bleed into the outcome
  • Shallow depth — covering every domain alone leaves less depth in each one
  • No cross-check — since the result is one person's opinion, there's nothing to validate it against
02

#Four Things Divided Review Delivers

ValueWhat You Get
Blind-spot coverageEach domain gets its own specialist, minimizing what falls through the cracks
Perspective diversityMarket, tech, finance, legal, and other lenses applied simultaneously
Weakness detectionStrength in one area no longer hides weakness in another
Conflict signalsWhere mentors disagree marks exactly where you should dig deeper
03

#OpenSeed's 17 Evaluation Roles

OpenSeed defines 17 evaluation roles: 7 core roles and 10 professional roles. Professional roles are matched to business relevance; the separate Chief Report Composer integrates applicable findings.

  • 7 core mentors — problem definition, market, finance, team, product, technology, and risk
  • 10 professional roles — law, patents, accounting, tax, credit, product management, credit guarantees, technology evaluation, franchising, and YC-style advice (matched by business relevance)
  • Chief Report Composer — a separate role that integrates applicable findings into the final report
TIP
OpenSeed publishes a full mentor directory on its site, so you can see exactly which domain each mentor covers before you submit.
04

#Operating Principles That Maximize the Value of Division

  1. Domain separation — each mentor evaluates only their own domain, with no opinions outside it
  2. Independent evaluation — mentors don't see each other's results before scoring
  3. Cited evidence — every score comes with the exact passage from your business plan that justifies it
  4. Conflict flagging — areas where mentors disagree are flagged separately for you
Summary.

#How to Put the Divided Review Results to Work

  1. Compare scores across mentors to identify your business plan's strong and weak domains
  2. Treat domains with the widest score gaps between mentors as your top priority for follow-up
  3. Check whether the Chief Report Composer's integrated report lines up with the individual domain scores
  4. Use the comments on your weakest domains directly as a revision guide
CTA
Professional roles are matched to the business and review context. Check the analysis-start screen for current pricing and conditions.
Advertisement

A Review Matched to Your Business

Domain specialists deliver scores and supporting evidence together.

Pre-submission business-plan review with clear service limitations

Start OpenSeed Review →

관련 AI 피드백 서비스.

AI 피드백
사업계획서 AI 추천 →
AI 피드백
예비창업패키지 점검 →
AI 피드백
초기창업패키지 점검 →
RELATED · Related pagesTechnology & Research
Using Academic Papers as Market Evidence in a Business Plan2026.10.01 · 7 minWhat Should Computer Science Students Learn When AI Can Write the Code?2026.07.28 · 8 minThe Real AI-Era Skill Is Not Prompting. It Is Reading and Critique.2026.07.28 · 8 minWhy One AI Isn't Enough — The Logic Behind Multi-Agent Review2026.07.24 · 7 minSame Business Plan, Different AI Models — How Often Does It Actually Catch the Number Errors?2026.07.14 · 9 min
← Back to Wiki